Opinion

Why we should not blame the ECB for low returns on German savings

The ECB has lowered its official interest rate several times in the last years and the rate is now at zero. In March of this year, it has in addition started a large sovereign bond purchase programme. Contrary to popular belief, however, the ECB is not the main driver of the decline in interest rates. 

By: Date: May 7, 2015 Topic: European Macroeconomics & Governance

This piece was originally published in Die Welt.

The ECB has lowered its official interest rate several times in recent years and the rate is now at zero. In March this year, it started in addition a large sovereign bond purchase programme. German commentators have been focusing on the negative effect of ECB policy on returns on German savings. Contrary to popular belief, however, the ECB is not the main driver of the decline in interest rates. The debate also ignores the appropriate policy response to the decline in interest rates.

Nominal interest rates have been falling for 30 years now. While in 1980, the US governments’ borrowing costs on a 10 year horizon amounted to around 13%, they declined to 8% in 1990, 5% in 2000 and to only 1.9% in April 2015. A similar picture emerges for Germany, where yields for the same type of bond falling from around 9% in 1980, to 5% in 2000 and now to 0.1%.

So what is behind this dramatic fall in interest rates, observed over the past 3 decades? Two factors are central: firstly the fall in inflation, and secondly the fall in real returns. Turning to the former, inflation rates in the 1980s were at about 3% in Germany; for the 2000s at 1.6% and currently the inflation forecast for the next 10 years is at 1.4% for the euro area. A similar picture emerges for the US.

A large part of the fall in interest rates is due to the falling inflation rates

A large part of the fall in interest rates is thus due to falling inflation rates. This is a success of better monetary policy management. Falling inflation rates do not reduce the return to savers. In fact, what matters for savers is the so-called real interest rate. Put differently, as a saver, I am interested in how many goods I can buy from the interest I receive from my savings, and this is measured by the real interest rate.

How have real interest rates developed? In both the US and Germany, real interest rates have fallen from levels of about 4%  to levels closer to 1% (see graph). With the recent economic upturn, real rates seem to have increased again.

Graph: ex-post real rates (US and DE).

Source: ThomsonReuters Datastream

So what drives this decline in real interest rates?  Real rates are determined by a whole set of economic factors, including growth prospects. Ultimately, it is economic performance that drives the return in investments. In a fast growing economy that is still building up its capital stock, real rates should be high as economic growth prospects are high. The opposite is true for an economy in a recessionary environment or an economy with already high capital stocks.

Long-term falling growth prospects are one of the main drivers of low real interest rates

Long-term falling growth prospects are therefore one of the main drivers of low real interest rates. This so-called secular stagnation is explained by demographic developments, increasing capital stocks and an absence of reforms. Moreover, the still rather weak economic outlook in the eurozone is also to be blamed for low returns on savings. Savers will not be awarded a higher interest rate simply because savings are plentiful and investment is low in a recession.

As the reasons behind low real rates are linked to secular stagnation, I would argue that an appropriate set of structural reforms is urgently needed to allow for proper business opportunities and innovation in the industrialized world. This is also particularly important in Germany. German corporations tend to invest abroad rather than in Germany, a development that is shown by the huge current account surplus, and is actually a concern which reflects the weakness of investment opportunities and the lack of demand in Germany. In addition to reform, the demand shortage needs to be addressed with public investment and reduced taxes on low-income households.

The ECB has only reacted to the weak economic situation and has reduced its interest rate to adapt to the weakening economy. The role of the ECB is to achieve the appropriate increase of inflation to its mandate of close but below 2%. Any premature move on increasing the interest rate would hamper the weak economic recovery. The resulting recession would keep investment depressed and returns low.

we have to ask what the right policies should be to address secular stagnation

The discussion therefore has to go beyond blaming the ECB for doing its job. Instead, we have to ask why real interest rates have been falling for so long, and what the right policies should be to address “secular stagnation”. Germany should implement substantial structural policies that increase domestic investment opportunities, thereby redirecting some of the savings to the German economy. It should also increase public investment in order to boost its long-term growth potential. Finally, Germany needs policies that ensure that low income households see their incomes raise and increase their consumption. Only with these changes in place can German savers expect to see their returns rising again.


Republishing and referencing

Bruegel considers itself a public good and takes no institutional standpoint.

Due to copyright agreements we ask that you kindly email request to republish opinions that have appeared in print to communication@bruegel.org.

View comments
Read article More on this topic More by this author

Blog Post

Economy of Intangibles

Economists have been discussing the implications of the rise of the intangible economy in relation to the secular stagnation hypothesis, and looking more generally into the policy implications it has for taxation. We review some recent contributions.

By: Silvia Merler Topic: Finance & Financial Regulation Date: July 16, 2018
Read article More on this topic More by this author

Opinion

Another slow year for the global economy

The factors that dragged down the global economy in 2015 will persist – and in some cases even intensify – in the new year.

By: Ashoka Mody Topic: Global Economics & Governance Date: January 5, 2016
Read about event

Past Event

Past Event

Secular Stagnation in Europe and Japan

This is the 3rd conference in a series of events jointly organised by Graduate School of Economics, Kobe University and Bruegel

Speakers: Grégory Claeys, Marcia De Wachter, Philipp Hartmann, Juan F. Jimeno, Toshiki Jinushi, Yoichi Matsubayashi, Ryuzo Miyao, Rainer Münz, Xavier Ragot, Paul Swaim, Coen Teulings, Atsuko Ueda, Natacha Valla, Guntram B. Wolff, Masahiko Yoshii and Naoyuki Yoshino Topic: European Macroeconomics & Governance, Global Economics & Governance Location: Bruegel, Rue de la Charité 33, 1210 Brussels Date: October 5, 2015
Read article More on this topic More by this author

Blog Post

Is the economy stationary?

What’s at stake: The question of whether capitalist economies are self-correcting and will eventually revert to mean growth has received renewed interest given the underperformance of most economies six years after the onset of the Great Recessions. While the idea of persistent high unemployment was central to Keynes’ General Theory, it was quickly abandoned by the neoclassical synthesis.

By: Jérémie Cohen-Setton Topic: European Macroeconomics & Governance Date: May 18, 2015
Read article More by this author

Blog Post

Secular stagnation and capital flows

What’s at stake: Former Chairman of the Federal Reserve and new blogger Ben Bernanke has generated many discussions this week by challenging the secular stagnation idea. Bernanke argues, in particular, that the stagnationists have failed to properly take into account how capital flows can mitigate or even eliminate the problems generated by secular stagnation at home.

By: Jérémie Cohen-Setton Topic: European Macroeconomics & Governance Date: April 7, 2015
Read article More on this topic

Blog Post

What is behind the reduction of private sector debt? Comparing Spain and the UK

Spain and the United Kingdom are going through a deleveraging process, with their private debt-to-GDP ratios dropping by around 18% in the United Kingdom and 15.5% in Spain from their respective peaks some years ago. However, the mechanics behind the deleveraging process show substantial differences between the two countries.

By: Pia Hüttl and Guntram B. Wolff Topic: European Macroeconomics & Governance Date: December 5, 2014
Read article More on this topic More by this author

Blog Post

The ECB’s balance sheet, if needed

In his press conference on November 6th, ECB President Mario Draghi pledged monetary stimulus, although only “if needed.” These words have won Mr. Draghi many admirers for his determination to move decisively forward. But the actions tell a different story. The “if needed” mantra is only the most recent example of the ECB’s congenital conservatism in dealing with the ever-unfolding crisis. Once again, the ECB is behind the curve even as a debt-deflation cycle is ongoing in the so-called “periphery.” Rather than a central bank that helps revive growth and inflation, the ECB has become a safety net for dealing with near-insolvency conditions. 

By: Ashoka Mody Topic: European Macroeconomics & Governance Date: December 3, 2014
Read article More on this topic More by this author

Blog Post

How can Europe avoid secular stagnation?

Larry Summers crystallized an important question in a recent speech: Has the world economy entered a period of “secular stagnation”? The slow recovery in the United States since the financial crisis is his starting point and he argues that secular stagnation could also retrospectively explain features of previous decades, such as low inflation.

By: Guntram B. Wolff Topic: Global Economics & Governance Date: November 25, 2014
Read article More by this author

Blog Post

Monetary policy cannot solve secular stagnation alone

Larry Summers crystallized an important development and question in a recent speech given at the IMF research conference: has the world economy entered a period of “secular stagnation”? The slow recovery in the US since the financial crisis is his starting point and he argues that secular stagnation could retrospectively also explain features of previous decades such as low inflation.

By: Guntram B. Wolff Topic: European Macroeconomics & Governance Date: October 24, 2014
Read article More by this author

Blog Post

Blogs review: The secular stagnation hypothesis

What’s at stake: On November 16, the Harvard economist and former Treasury Secretary Lawrence Summers gave a provocative talk at an International Monetary Fund conference, where he argued that an age of secular stagnation, in which the equilibrium interest rate is negative, might explain the lack of inflationary pressure we experienced in the boom years of the previous decades and the slow recovery following the 2007 crisis.

By: Jérémie Cohen-Setton Topic: European Macroeconomics & Governance, Global Economics & Governance Date: August 25, 2014
Read article

Video

Video

Secular stagnation in today's economy. How can it be addressed?

This video was filmed as part of the China-Europe-US Economists Symposium in Beijing. In it Gregory Claeys, Research Fellow at Bruegel, discusses secular stagnation – defined as a long period of low growth, low employment, low inflation, and low long-term interest rates. This concept, according to Claeys, could explain the current period of recovery in […]

By: Grégory Claeys and Zsolt Darvas Topic: European Macroeconomics & Governance Date: June 17, 2014
Read article More on this topic More by this author

Opinion

Monetary policy cannot solve secular stagnation

What role can quantitative easing play? I am not quite as negative on QE as Olivier Blanchard but certainly agree that it cannot fundamentally solve the problem.

By: Guntram B. Wolff Topic: Global Economics & Governance Date: January 10, 2014
Load more posts